Why Re-gear your 914?
by Race914
The gearing in your 914 determines your acceleration, shift points, and top speed,
along with the RPMs across the MPH range. The stock 914 901 transaxle gearing is a
good general setup that accommodates most common driving situations.
NOTE: Most 914 owners will never need to consider re-gearing.
However, you may want to consider re-gearing if you:
-
Change Tire diameter
- Change to a Power Plant with a different torque curve and/or RPM range
- Desire to tune your ratios to match your driving style: Autocross, Road Courses, etc.
Here are some symptoms you may experience that can be resolved with re-gearing:
- Uncomfortable RPM at cruising speed, e.g. you are ‘in between gears’ at your cruising speed because
you have too high RPMs in one gear, or too low in the next
- You don’t have ‘the right gear’ for your autocross or road course corners,
e.g. you are ‘in between gears’ in the corner because you either have too high RPMs in one gear,
or too low in the next
- You don’t have ‘the right gear’ for the road course straightaway,
e.g. you don’t use 5th at all or you don’t even hit redline in 4th by the end of the straightaway
The 914 901 Gear Ratio Workbook helps you do “what if” models to see how changing gears affects
your RPM at different speeds as well as your shift point entry/exit RPMs for each gear.
This spreadsheet has four worksheets (Tabs):
- Tab 1 - 901 Gear Ratio Model – Provides graphs of the stock gearing as a baseline and allows the
user to enter their tire diameter, redline and gear selections to do ‘what if’ models.
- Tab 2 - 901 Gear Ratios & RPM-MPH table – Table of all 901 gear ratios along with a
RPM/MPH table to assist with gear selections. RPM/MPH is based on your tire diameter entered on Tab 1
- Tab 3 – 901 3rd & 4th-5th “FLIP” Chart – Some 3rd gears can be used as 4th/5th gears
and vice-a-versa. This table shows which gears will interchange.
- Tab 4 – 901 Transaxle Codes & Gear sets – Different model 901s had different stock gear sets.
This table helps you decode which 901 you have or are looking to buy.
914 901 Gear Ratio Workbook
As a baseline, the
Stock 914-4 gear ratio chart is below. Note that 1) Porsche uses
letter codes for its gear sets (“A” thru “ZD”)
you’ll see this notation whenever 914 901 gear ratios are
discussed, and 2) The letter codes refer to the number of teeth on
each gear of the pair, e.g. “A” = 11:34, this is
important since some gear sets have letters stamped on them that are
not related to the actual ratio. The stock 914-4 901 gear set is
“A”-“F”-“N”-“V”-“ZD”.
The complete gear ratio table, along with teeth counts, is included
in the 914 901 Gear Ratio Excel sheet.
Figure
1. Stock 914-4 901 Gear Ratios, with 205-50x15 tires and a 5500 RPM
redline
Some thoughts on how
to use the 914 901 Gear Ratio Workbook follow. This is
definitely not the only way to approach this project, probably not
the best way, just the way that has worked well for me.
General
approach
In general, it’s
hard to create a ‘perfect’ set of ratios and you’ll
probably have to settle for some trade offs. While it’s
usually not possible to have ‘the perfect’ gear for each
corner, here are some things to think about to get you that good
compromise.
Road course
example
Things to consider
in order of priority:
Corner onto the longest
straight
Top speed on the longest
straight
Shift points of the ‘in
between’ gears
Corner onto the longest straight
Start
with the corner preceding the longest straight. The acceleration
coming out of this corner and your resulting top speed at the end of
this straight has the biggest impact on your lap times. For more
info on this, refer to “Driving in Competition” by
Alan Johnson, available at your favorite book vendor.
It
‘s critical that you can take that corner as fast as your
handling setup will allow you, and also be at a point in your
engine’s power band affording the best possible acceleration
onto the straight.
Let’s
assume you can take the corner before the longest straight at 40mph.
Now refer to figure 1 and you’ll see that you are either at
your shift point in 2nd @ 4800RPM or @ 3200RPM in 3rd.
This isn’t the best case for a 40 MPH corner. Now look at
figure 2, the example Road Race setup which is a
“A”-“HA”-“KA”-“Q”-“V”
setup. Now at 40mph in 2nd gear you are at 4100RPM
eliminating the ‘in between gears’ situation and allowing
good acceleration onto the straight.
Note
that 2nd gear is part of your main shaft and the options
are “F”, “GA”, and “GB” (see the
gear table on the 914 901 Gear Ratio Workbook) if you
need more options for 2nd, you can go to a 904 main shaft
which allows you to exchange 2nd gear ratios just like
1st, and 3rd-5th. But be
forewarned, 904 main shafts are not cheap! Alternatives to a 904
main shaft for 2nd gear changes are discussed in the
Summary section at the end of this article.
Depending
on your tire diameter, engine power band, and your favorite track’s
configuration, you’ll have to determine the best gear for you
on the corner before the longest straight using the 914 901
Gear Ratio Workbook. Start with the MPH you take the corner
then find the gear that puts you in the RPM ‘sweet’ spot
to catapult you down the straight.
Top
Speed on the Longest Straight
The
second consideration is your top speed on the longest straight. The
stock “ZD” fifth gear doesn’t help on the track as
it’s an overdrive gear and acceleration is barely achievable in
this gear (great for gas mileage on the highway though!) On many
tracks a stock geared 914 will never use 5th and many
times not hit redline in 4th. The objective here is to
accelerate as fast as possible by keeping the engine in its power
band with no bogging between gears and also not hitting 5th
gear redline too early. Best case is, you’re just reaching
redline in 5th when you reach your braking point for the next turn.
To help zero in on the correct top gear, take notes on your MPH or
RPM at the end of the straight with your current gearbox. From there
you have a good starting point to select a top gear. For our
example, let’s assume with the length of the straight away
85MPH @ 5000RPM in 4th gear is your top speed. Now you
need to factor in that having a close ratio gearbox you’ll
accelerate faster and have a higher MPH at the end of the straight.
As a ballpark assume you’ll gain 5% top speed. So from 85
you’ll probably go up to 90. Now to figure 2. In this case a
your stock “V” 4th gear is perfect as a fifth
as it will let go you to 90mph at your redline of 5500. Best case is
this happens right as you reach the braking point for the next turn.
Depending
on your tire diameter, engine power band, your favorite tracks
configuration, you’ll have to determine the best top gear for
you using the 914 901 Gear Ratio Workbook.
Shift
points of the ‘in between’ gears
In
the example above, we’ve talked about 2nd & 5th
so let’s look at 3rd & 4th. Ideally
you’d like to have a perfect gear for every turn on the track
so you could set them as with 2nd gear and use the
remaining corner MPHs, but you also have to think about efficiently
getting from 2nd to 5th down the straightaways.
You probably can come pretty close to a good gear set by selecting
your 3rd & 4th to give you the desired RPM
drop when up shifting. Again the goals is to drop the RPMs from
redline into the heart of your engines torque band when up shifting.
In the attached example my RPM entry points are as follows: 2nd
to 3rd 4359 RPM, 3rd to 4th 4391
RPM, and 4th to 5th 4527 RPM. Here are the
charts from the 914 901 Gear Ratio Excel sheet.
Figure 2. Example Road Race
setup, with 205-50x15 tires and a 5500 RPM redline
The
setup in this example “KA”-“Q”-“V”
is also one of the economy short gear sets:
3rd – your
stock “ZD” 5th is ‘flipped’ to
make a “KA” and moved to 3rd
5th – your
stock “V” 4th is moved to 5th
4th - You need to
find a “Q” gear for your new 4th
See the “901 3rd &
4th-5th
“FLIP” Chart” on the 914 901 Gear
Ratio Workbook for more info on ‘flipping gears’.
Another popular combination for longer tracks is “M”-“S”-“X”.
Of course what will work for you is dependent on your tire diameter,
engine power band, and the specific track you are tuning for. That’s
where the spreadsheet comes in handy to do your “what if”
calculations to model your RPM and MPH at your shift points before
buying and changing out any gears.
Autocross
Example
Autocross setup is
similar except the courses are lower speed and you usually need to
tune 1st-3rd. Also, many cars are driven to
autocross events so in those cases a reasonable highway cruising RPM
needs to be retained, unlike Road Race setups where that setup would
be detrimental to your straightaway top speed.
Here is a setup that
requires no new gears to be purchased. By ‘flipping’ the
stock 3rd & 5th gears you get a lower 3rd
gear and a 5th that is still acceptable for short trips on
the highway. See the “flip chart” on the 914 901
Gear Ratio Workbook:
Figure
3. Example Autocross Setup, with 205-50x15 tires and a 5500 RPM
redline
You can see from the
graph that this setup give close ratio gears for 1st - 3rd
and leaves 4th & 5th for getting to and
from the event. The next step for your Autocross setup is to dial in
your 2nd gear. If the “F” 2nd
isn’t working out for your typical autocross MPH, try the “GA”,
or “GB” main shafts in the model. If they don’t
fit the bill either, you’ll need to a) find a 904 main shaft so
can you can interchange gears same as with the 1st and
3rd-5th positions, or b) consider the
alternative for other 2nd gear options noted in the
Summary section below. Of course what will work for you is dependent
on your tire diameter, engine power band, and the situations you are
tuning for.
Street Example
Determining gear
ratios for the street isn’t quite as involved. The issue is
usually that the changes made to the car: tire diameter, power plant
swap, etc., has resulted in less than acceptable RPMs at commonly
driven speeds. For example, our 914-6 street/track car is running
the “M”-“S”-“X” setup and driving
at 70mph on the highway is only OK for short trips. A higher 5th
would definitely be needed for longer trips… The same holds
true for in city driving, you may be ‘in between’ gears
at your normal cruising speed.
For this
application, use the spreadsheet to model the speeds you typically
drive at and change out the gears until you get your desired RPMs at
your desired MPHs. Remember to pay attention to the RPM exit &
entry points so you also end up with acceptable ‘steps’
between the gears. Also make sure you end up with a 5th
that is appropriate for your highway trips.
Summary
The 914 901
Gear Ratio Workbook allows you to model and evaluate
different gear combinations without buying gears or rebuilding your
transaxle. While this provides valuable information, I recommend
that you always talk to others who have already taken on this
project, especially those that have a similar car setup and similar
objectives. If possible try to get a ride in, or better yet a test
drive a car with the modification you are considering before
embarking on the project. Always take advantage of the experience of
other 914World members before spending money!!
Where
can I get gears? How do I change out gear sets?
Once
you’ve decided to go forward with this project and have worked
out your ‘perfect’ gear set. There are 914World members
that provide products and services for your 901 transaxle.
Dr Evil provides a
901 information/diagnostic/rebuild service which includes
re-gearing.
Racer Chris
provides products
& services to provide more 2nd gear
options beyond “F”, “GA” and “GB”,
without having to buy a 904 main shaft.
Rich Bontempi provides
products & services including gear set planning
consultation, gear-sets, 901 diagnostics and rebuilding services.
Or, for the DIY crowd, 914World member contributions from the
“Lapuwali Classic Thread Forum”:
DNHunt --
There sure are a lot of parts in a 901 box,
now I'm going to try to put them back in
Bondo --
914 transmission disassembly, Step by step,
so it can go back together
Search for related discussion threads here:
914World Search page
Member
Gear Set Library
Lastly,
but probably most importantly, I've created a "library" of
member gear sets used for Autocross, Street, and Track to provide a
consolidated repository of 'what works for who-where' along with
associated notes or discussion threads to help you with your research
for that 'perfect' gear set.
Important Note!
The
‘right’ gear set for you is particular to many factors.
To list a few, the car’s weight, suspension, engine, and
DRIVER! Don’t take the gear-sets listed for a particular
application as your
ideal setup. Contact the owner, compare corner speeds, suspension
setups, engine characteristics, driving skills, etc. All of these
factors play into what will work for you.
The
“Member Gear Ratio Library” can be viewed on the
914 901 Gear Ratios, Spreadsheet, Member Gear Set Library
thread in the Paddock.
If
you’d like to contribute, please post on the
914 901 Gear Ratios, Spreadsheet, Member Gear Set Library
thread and include: Applicable Category, Track (if applicable),
Engine (cc & cylinders), HP, Redline RPM, Tire Diameter, Weight
w/driver, 1st-5th gear codes and any short comment that you’d
like to pass on, or better yet provide the link to the applicable
914World discussion thread.
|